Siguenos
0
Mi Carrito
$0
0
Stonehearst Asylum Review — An Absolutely Forgettable Film
The film concludes with a double revelation. While it is revealed that Dr. Lamb was an army surgeon who suffered a mental break after executing his own wounded soldiers, the final "gotcha" centers on Edward. The man claiming to be "Edward Newgate" is actually an escaped patient with pseudologia fantastica who fell in love with Eliza during a lecture. The real Dr. Newgate arrives later to find the imposter and Eliza living happily together in Italy under the name "Lamb".
Edward soon becomes infatuated with Eliza Graves (Kate Beckinsale), a refined patient institutionalized for "hysteria" after attacking her abusive husband. However, the hospital's utopian facade crumbles when Edward discovers the true staff, led by Dr. Salt (Michael Caine), imprisoned in the building's basement.
The story begins on Christmas Eve, 1899, as Edward Newgate (Jim Sturgess), a naive Oxford graduate, arrives at the remote Stonehearst Asylum to complete his medical residency. He is welcomed by the charismatic Dr. Silas Lamb (Ben Kingsley), who practices "moral treatment"—allowing patients to roam free and dine with staff rather than endure shackles and sedation.
: The film highlights the barbaric treatments of the era, such as hydrotherapy and electrical stimulation, contrasting them with the more humane (if chaotic) environment created by the inmates.
Critics largely praised the ensemble cast but were divided on the film's tone. Reviewers from The Guardian enjoyed it as a "supremely entertaining Gothic thriller," while Roger Ebert contributors found it "surprisingly dull visually" despite its authentic production design.