Just like any contractor group, skill varies. Some clients have reported massive leveling issues, poorly hung doors, or improperly installed moisture barriers because the specific crew lacked modern building science training.
“Darren Carty and the Amish crew he works for built this for us a few weeks ago. Their quote was much cheaper than others we had got. He was very professional and showed up exactly when he said. We recommend him very highly and will definitely be repeat...” Facebook · Amy Tischner · 8 months ago
“People have romantic notions about the quality of Amish work. But the fact is that, setting aside their religious practices, their work is no better or worse than any other contractor and you're just as likely to get a contractor as a good one between Amish...” Reddit · r/Homebuilding · 7 months ago 💡 Pro-Tips for Hiring in Kentucky amish pole barns kentucky
Some independent crews do not carry workers' compensation or standard liability insurance. This leaves the liability on the property owner if someone gets injured on your property. 💬 What Property Owners Are Saying
Hiring an Amish crew to build a pole barn in Kentucky generally yields exceptionally high satisfaction, though experiences vary depending on the specific crew you hire. Just like any contractor group, skill varies
Many traditional Amish crews do not use phones, internet, or standard modern transport. Communication usually happens through a non-Amish driver or middleman, and transactions are often expected in cash.
Crews are often praised on community groups for their pricing and punctuality: Their quote was much cheaper than others we had got
However, homeowners on construction forums urge buyers to look past the "Amish label" and vet the specific crew: