Reviewers have noted both strengths and potential weaknesses in his arguments:
Paul Starobin's is generally reviewed as a well-paced, practical examination of a post-American-dominant world. Critics describe it as an accessible starting point for those interested in futurism, avoiding both apocalyptic and utopian extremes. Key Themes and Scenarios After America
: Power shared among several large nations. The Chinese Century : China as the dominant global leader. Reviewers have noted both strengths and potential weaknesses
: The book is praised for its concise summaries, strong historical sketching of the late 20th century, and its ability to provide plausible outcomes supported by factual information. The Chinese Century : China as the dominant global leader
: Some critics, such as those at Scoop News and the Palestine Chronicle , have challenged his framing of the U.S. empire as "accidental" rather than purposeful. Others find his analysis of the Middle East to be somewhat "modernist" or traditional, potentially overlooking the U.S.'s role in regional instability. After America - Palestine Chronicle
: Power decentralizing to major urban hubs. Universal Civilization : A more integrated global society. Critical Perspectives
Starobin explores the decline of American "exceptionalism" and the idea of the U.S. as a "global policeman". He argues that a shift away from U.S. hegemony is not necessarily negative for the country and could lead to new forms of success. The book outlines five primary future scenarios: : A fragmented world with no central authority.